If metal is your only realistic foreign object risk and you are not packaging in aluminum, a metal detector is usually sufficient. X-ray inspection is worthwhile if glass, stone, bone, or dense plastics are documented hazards, if you need to inspect products in aluminum or metal packaging, or if you want to simultaneously check fill levels and product completeness. A test with your product will provide clarity.
This decision-making guide is based on primary sources: the IFS Foreign Body Management Guideline (2025), the BRCGS Food Safety Standard (Issue 9, 2022), the German Radiation Protection Ordinance, and data from the EU Rapid Alert System. RaymanTech offers both technologies, X-ray inspection systems as well as Metal detectors for the food industry. We therefore have no interest in recommending the more expensive device to you.
A metal detector detects metal, while an X-ray system detects differences in density. Almost everything else follows from this.
The metal detector generates an alternating electromagnetic field. Conductive or magnetic parts disrupt this field. Iron is the easiest to find, while non-magnetic stainless steel is the most difficult. It is less well known that the orientation of a part plays a role. According to the IFS Foreign Body Management Guideline (IFS, 2025), a wire-shaped iron part is detected well when aligned longitudinally to the direction of transport, but poorly when aligned transversely. For non-ferrous metal and non-magnetic stainless steel, it is exactly the opposite. Shavings provide an even weaker signal than wire.
The X-ray system measures how much radiation the product absorbs. A foreign body is only noticeable if it is significantly denser than its surroundings. The IFS Guideline (2025) classifies this for water-containing foods (density 1.00 g/cm³) as follows:
The detection of plastic is therefore never guaranteed. Whether a plastic part becomes visible depends on the material, size, orientation, and product, and this can only be clarified through testing. In poultry, thin, poorly calcified bones are close to muscle tissue in terms of density. For such cases, dual-energy X-ray systems are intended, which evaluate two energy ranges.
Glass and metal lead the EU reports, with plastic in third place. An analysis of the EU Rapid Alert System for Food and Feed (RASFF) (Microplastics/MDPI, 2024) found a total of 402 reports regarding glass, metal, plastic, insects, and bones between 2020 and 2023; plastic accounted for 25.1%. 90.4% of glass reports, 77.9% of metal reports, and 65.3% of plastic reports were classified as a serious risk. In Germany, according to the Federal Association of Food Chemists in Public Service (BLC, 2026), 51 reports on lebensmittelwarnung.de cited foreign bodies as the reason in 2025.
X-ray covers more types of foreign bodies and packaging, while the metal detector is more cost-effective and has an advantage when it comes to finding certain metals. The table shows the most important differences.
product quality, but it is not the better metal detector for every product. The deciding factor is which hazards your HACCP analysis documents and how your product is packaged.
In the production line, detection limits are usually significantly higher than the best-case values found in data sheets because the product and packaging are contributing factors. For example: According to its data sheet, the RaymanTech dual-energy system RXD-MS-2416 achieves a best-case detection of a 0.3 mm stainless steel sphere and a 0.8 mm glass sphere. The IFS Guideline (2025), by contrast, lists typical sizes that X-ray systems detect in everyday production (sphere diameter):
Key takeaway: For cans and jars, typical X-ray detection limits are about 50% higher than those for plastic or paper packaging. Plan based on your product's specific values, not the best-case figures from a brochure.
It is similar with metal detectors. In a real-world case from the IFSQN professional forum, limits of 6 to 8 mm were agreed upon for frozen meat blocks—far above the 1.5 to 2.5 mm cited in many guides. This is an individual case, but it demonstrates that the values achievable for your product can only be determined using your product.
With metal detectors, conductive products reduce sensitivity; with X-rays, thickness, density, and homogeneity are the deciding factors. Wet, salty, warm, or frozen products conduct electricity themselves. The metal detector must filter out this inherent signal, which reduces its sensitivity. Multi-frequency technology mitigates this effect but does not eliminate it. With X-rays, conductivity and temperature play almost no role: the more uniform the product, the smaller the detectable foreign object.
To a limited extent, yes—specifically for ferrous parts. It is often said that metal detectors are fundamentally unsuitable here, but ferrous-in-foil detectors can detect iron even in aluminum packaging. The BRCGS standard (Issue 9, 2022, clause 4.10.3.4) explicitly allows for products in foil containers to be tested using only a ferrous test piece. However, non-ferrous metal, stainless steel, glass, and bone remain detectable in aluminum packaging only via X-ray. Alternatively, you can inspect with the metal detector before packaging.
An X-ray system can also monitor fill levels, completeness, seal integrity, and shape defects using the same scan. It detects fill levels in opaque containers, missing or broken parts, and product trapped in the seal. Mass can also be estimated via grayscale values. If you currently have separate inspection steps for these tasks, this consolidation should be included in your cost-benefit analysis. Learn more in our X-ray scanners for food.
No, none of the major standards mandate X-ray inspection. According to the BRCGS Food Safety Standard (Issue 9, 2022, clause 4.10.3.1), metal detection is the standard procedure. A facility can only opt out if a risk assessment shows that metal detection does not improve food safety. Such an exemption is generally based on a more effective method, such as X-ray, fine sieves, or filtration, and must be documented.
For both methods, testing requires: test pieces with a known, risk-based diameter, at normal belt speed, with proof of detection and rejection. However, the BRCGS standard specifies different test positions. For a metal detector, the test piece belongs in the center of the aperture, where the field is weakest. For X-ray, it belongs in the least sensitive area, which may be near the radiation source or near the detector. A test routine adopted from a metal detector may therefore be testing in the wrong place when using X-ray.
In practice, test piece sizes are often dictated by retail customers through their own requirements. A metal detector alone, for example, cannot fulfill a "zero glass" policy. We describe in detail how metal detectors are integrated as CCPs in our Metal detectors for the food industry.
A metal detector is less expensive to purchase and operate than an X-ray system. With X-ray, wear parts are added to the purchase price: according to manufacturer specifications, the X-ray generator and line detector are the most expensive replacement parts, in addition to cooling and regular inspections. Therefore, compare quotes over the entire service life, including maintenance, spare parts, and mandatory inspections.
For a fully shielded device with type approval, the effort is less than many expect:
Not in the sense of food law. The Codex Alimentarius standard for irradiated foods (CXS 106-1983, Rev. 2003) explicitly does not apply to radiation from inspection equipment. The US FDA limits the dose from inspection X-ray tubes up to 500 kVp to a maximum of 10 Gray (21 CFR 179.21).
False rejects cost money with both methods and should therefore be part of every test. A user on the IFSQN forum reports a false reject rate of around 0.54% on a pouch line despite fine-tuning; the causes were particles in the packaging and changing laminates. When conducting a product test, make sure to ask for the false reject rate in addition to the detection limit.
A combination is worthwhile when different hazards exist at different points in the line. A typical pattern: a metal detector protects the equipment at the goods-in stage or before slicers and mills, while an X-ray system checks the packaged product at the end of the line for glass, stone, bone, and completeness. For raw produce from the field, such as nuts or vegetables, it can also be the other way around.
For most lines with a purely metal risk and plastic or paper packaging, a well-adjusted metal detector remains the most economical solution. We recommend X-ray as soon as non-metallic hazards are documented or inspection must take place within metal packaging, as a metal detector cannot physically perform this task. For an overview of all methods, see our page on Foreign object detection in production.
RaymanTech offers trial installations. Contact us if you would like to have your product tested in its original packaging. We will tell you honestly whether a metal detector, an X-ray system, or both make sense for your line: Request a product test at RaymanTech.
Sie möchten wissen, wie sich das in Ihrer Linie umsetzen lässt? Auf der passenden Produktseite finden Sie Technik, Bauformen und Einsatzbereiche im Detail. Für eine Einschätzung Ihrer Anwendung sprechen Sie direkt mit unseren Inspektionsexperten.
Produkttest anfragenNeither is inherently better. X-ray systems detect a wider range of foreign objects and work effectively with aluminum packaging. Metal detectors are more cost-effective, easier to integrate into existing lines, and often more sensitive when detecting thin stainless steel in lightweight products. The deciding factors are your documented hazards and your specific packaging.
Only dense plastics such as PVC or PTFE are detectable, and even then, only depending on the product and size. According to the IFS guidelines (2025), polypropylene and nylon are considered non-detectable. There is no guarantee for the detection of plastic.
Limited capability: Ferrous-in-foil systems can only detect ferrous metal parts. For non-ferrous metals, stainless steel, and non-metallic contaminants in aluminum packaging, X-ray inspection is required, or alternatively, metal detection prior to packaging.
Inspection is not considered food irradiation (Codex CXS 106). In accordance with § 21 of the Radiation Protection Ordinance (StrlSchV), fully shielded devices must not emit more than 3 µSv/h at a distance of 0.1 m, and according to DGUV regulations, the annual dose for employees remains below 1 mSv.
No. BRCGS requires metal detection. It is possible to waive this requirement with a risk assessment, typically if a more effective method such as X-ray is used. Retail customers may impose stricter requirements.