None of the major standards for the food industry mandate a fixed test piece size for metal detectors. IFS Food 8, BRCGS Issue 9, and FSSC 22000 require you to define, validate, and document sensitivity, testing frequency, rejection, and record-keeping based on your risk analysis. Specific millimeter values only arise from retailer requirements, your HACCP plan, and validation using your own products.
This article examines the clauses applicable to metal detection in the food industry, identifying where the standards are clear and where the frequently cited "standard values" do not actually originate from the standards themselves.
There are three levels of regulation for metal detection that are often conflated: legislation, certification standards, and customer requirements.
IFS Food 8 has been mandatory for audits since January 1, 2024 (IFS, 2023). Chapter 4.12 is critical for metal detection:
BRCGS is significantly more specific (BRCGS, 2022):
FSSC 22000 is based on ISO 22000 and the prerequisite programs of the ISO/TS 22002 series. Additional requirement 2.5.11 (d) from version 6 requires a risk assessment that determines the need for and type of foreign object detection; if a facility decides against it, the justification must be available as documented information. Audit practice shows that this is not just a formality: according to the Foundation FSSC (2026), physical contamination is one of the most frequent non-conformities in version 6 audits. For your audit, the wording of the scheme version under which you are certified is always the authoritative source.
If metal detection is classified as a Critical Control Point (CCP), the following applies: the critical limit is the validated sensitivity per metal type, monitoring is the test piece check, and the corrective action is to isolate and re-test. Consequently, test piece size, testing frequency, and documentation are directly tied to your HACCP plan rather than an external standard.
Key takeaway: None of the three standards specifies a test piece size in millimeters; all require a justified, validated, and documented determination. BRCGS is most specific regarding rejection and testing procedures, while IFS is more specific regarding maintenance with its 12-month deadline.
Neither IFS Food 8 nor BRCGS Issue 9 prescribes fixed test piece sizes for iron, non-ferrous metals, and stainless steel. Values such as "3 mm iron, 4 mm non-ferrous, 4 mm stainless steel" are often referred to as the standard, but they do not appear in the standard texts. According to BRCGS 4.10.3.4, only the procedure is binding:
The IFS guideline for effective foreign body management (Version 3, IFS 2025) adds: test pieces should be as small as possible, customer specifications must be taken into account, and damaged test pieces must be replaced. It also points out an effect that test spheres do not replicate: a rod-shaped iron object (e.g., wire) is detected well when aligned with the direction of travel, but poorly when positioned crosswise or upright; for non-ferrous and non-magnetic stainless steel, the opposite is true. Shavings produce an even weaker signal than wire.
A figure from US authorities serves as an upper-limit guideline: the FDA classifies hard or sharp foreign bodies between 7 and 25 mm in length in ready-to-eat products as adulteration. According to the FDA, such foreign bodies rarely cause injury if they are under 7 mm, except in high-risk groups such as infants, surgical patients, and the elderly (FDA, CPG Sec. 555.425, 2005). For baby food or hospital meals, your test pieces should therefore be chosen to be significantly smaller.
Our recommendation: Define the test piece size as the smallest sphere that your system reliably detects and rejects with your product, your packaging, and your aperture size at full belt speed, and document this validation. Do not adopt values from tables that you have not confirmed with your own product.
According to BRCGS, an inline metal detector must be tested at least at the start and end of production; the frequency in between must take into account customer requirements and your ability to quarantine products (4.10.1.3, 4.10.3.4). IFS refers to a risk-based frequency (4.12.5). Common additional occasions in practice include product changes, program changes, malfunctions, and cleaning.
The crucial connection is stated in BRCGS 4.10.1.3: If a test fails, all products since the last successful test must be isolated, quarantined, and re-examined. Your test interval is therefore not just a formality; it determines how much stock you must hold back in the event of a failure. A calculation example: at 60 packs per minute, a two-hour interval means up to 7,200 packs that must be re-tested.
Also, pay attention to belt speed: the IFS guideline (2025) points out that in start-stop operation, the speed may drop below the critical transport speed; products that were in the tunnel at that moment should be re-tested.
BRCGS does not definitively specify exactly which fail-safe functions a metal detector must have, but it does require that the fail-safe systems for detection and rejection be tested during routine checks (4.10.3.4). The IFS guideline (2025) is more specific: it mentions sensors for compressed air failure, for rejection confirmation, and for a full rejection bin.
Retailer codes of practice may go beyond this. According to an overview by Thermo Fisher Scientific (2019) on retailer requirements, these include, for example:
The requirements of your own customers are the deciding factor. Clarify these before making a new purchase, as retrofitting confirmation sensors and locked bins is usually more complex than having them installed at the factory.
A test log must at least include the product, the tester, the time, the test piece, the result, and any actions taken. BRCGS 4.10.3.3 requires a procedure with defined responsibilities, sensitivity per product, method and frequency of testing, and recording of results. The IFS guideline (2025) lists the following as minimum contents for a test entry:
Add the time of the last successful test, as this defines the scope of the quarantine in the event of a failure.
Most metal detectors in the food industry use a balanced coil system: a metal object disrupts the electromagnetic field as it passes through, and the signal triggers the rejection process. Different designs are used depending on the product:
Moist, salty, or warm products generate their own signal (product effect), which limits the achievable sensitivity, especially with stainless steel. You can find an overview of designs in our summary of metal detectors for product inspection; we showcase industry-specific versions in the Metal detectors for the food industry.
Limitations: Metal detectors cannot detect glass, stone, bone, or plastic. In these cases, an X-ray scanners for food can help, though only for foreign objects that are denser than the product itself. The IFS Guideline (2025), for example, classifies polypropylene (0.90 g/cm³) in water-based foods as non-detectable, while PVC (1.70 g/cm³) is considered detectable depending on the product and size. Plastic detection is therefore never guaranteed. We describe which methods are suitable for specific foreign object risks under Foreign object detection in product inspection.
Whether your line meets the requirements of IFS, BRCGS, or your retail specifications depends on your product: product effect, aperture size, belt speed, and rejection systems. RaymanTech supports you in selecting the appropriate Metal detectors for the food industry and with validation for your specific application. To get an assessment of your line, please feel free to use the consultation with the RaymanTech team.
Sie möchten wissen, wie sich das in Ihrer Linie umsetzen lässt? Auf der passenden Produktseite finden Sie Technik, Bauformen und Einsatzbereiche im Detail. Für eine Einschätzung Ihrer Anwendung sprechen Sie direkt mit unseren Inspektionsexperten.
Metalldetektoren für die Lebensmittelindustrie ansehenNo, there is no EU law that mandates the use of a metal detector. Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 requires a HACCP-based procedure, and Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 prohibits unsafe food. In practice, the requirement for a detector arises from BRCGS Issue 9 (4.10.3.1), risk analyses conducted in accordance with IFS or FSSC 22000, and specific customer requirements.
IFS and BRCGS do not mandate specific test piece sizes. BRCGS requires spherical test pieces with a known diameter chosen based on risk, labeled by size and material, and separated into ferrous, stainless steel, and typically non-ferrous categories. You define the specific millimeter values through validation or according to retailer specifications.
According to BRCGS, an inline metal detector must be tested at least at the start and end of production, with additional testing in between at a frequency that accounts for customer requirements and your ability to quarantine products. IFS requires a risk-based frequency. The longer the interval, the more product you will need to quarantine and re-inspect in the event of a failed test.
Clause 4.12.4 of IFS Food 8 requires maintenance to be performed at least once every 12 months, as well as whenever significant changes occur.
Fail-safe means that if a system component fails, no uninspected product can pass through unnoticed. Typical examples include sensors for ejection confirmation, full or open ejection bins, and compressed air failure. BRCGS requires these functions to be included in routine testing.
For metallic foreign objects, usually yes; for glass, stone, bone, or plastic, no. Whether additional X-ray inspection, sieves, or magnets are required depends on your hazard analysis; FSSC 22000 and BRCGS require a documented assessment for this.